National Character Area 59

Wirral - Landscape Change

Monitoring Landscape Change

Drivers for change
The Wirral is a coastal landscape formed by the Dee and Merseyside estuaries, with characteristic parklands, pastoral fields, and sandstone ridges subject to both developmental and recreational pressures. Internationally important habitats along the coast and estuary are under pressure from tourism and impacts of climate change, including rising sea levels, erosion, and increased storminess. Additionally, increased development at the fringes of existing settlements may impact the characteristic pastoral and coastal character, through coalescence and further habitat fragmentation.

Monitoring landscape change
The most recent monitoring of landscape change within NCAs forms part of the Environmental Improvement Plan Environmental Indicator Framework. This includes indicator G1: Changes in landscape and waterscape character, informed by indicator component G1a: Changes in the landscape characteristics of NCAs in England.

Indicator component G1a measures the extent to which landscape change is achieving the aspirational landscape outcomes described in the NCA Statements of Environmental Opportunity (SEOs). For this purpose, SEOs across all NCAs are distilled into 34 Super Landscape Objectives (SLOs).

NCAs with broadly similar character and pressures for change have been grouped into 18 sub-Agricultural Landscape Types (sub-ALTs) that represent rural, urban and coastal landscapes. Equal numbers of relevant SLOs were identified for monitoring within each sub-ALT and their associated NCAs. These SLOs were assessed based on changes between 2015 – 2023 (or the closest approximations to those dates with the data available). The results of each SLO were combined to form an integrated view of overall landscape change within each NCA during this time period.

For further details on this landscape monitoring, refer to the G1a Landscape Change Atlas and report, which are also available via the Landscape Change Evidence Hub.

Results of G1a: Changes in the landscape characteristics within this NCA
Displayed below is the result of the medium term change assessment which considers the changes in (simplified) overall trend categories for the two short term periods of 2015-2019 and 2019-2023.

This section includes:

  • the overall trend for this NCA for the short term change period 2019-2023
  • the 2019-2023 results of the underlying analysis for each of the individual Super Landscape Objectives considered relevant to the NCA; this includes the ‘provisional status’ (i.e. current understanding of state/condition) and the ‘change trend’ associated with each SLO.

Reporting of the 2015-2019 time period can be seen in the short term change results of G1a: Changes in the landscape characteristics within this NCA below.

Additional information on landscape change

Short term change results of G1a: Changes in the landscape characteristics within this NCA

Listed below are:

    • the overall trend for this NCA for short term change period 2015-2019
    • the results of the underlying analysis for each of the individual Super Landscape Objectives considered relevant to the NCA; this includes the “provisional status” (i.e. current understanding of state/condition) and the “change trend” associated with each SLO for short term change period 2015-2019.

The following SLOs are considered relevant to this NCA. The current provisional status of each objective and the assessment of change (expressed as a trend) is listed below. The overall integrated trend assessment is also listed.

2015 - 2019 change


Landscape change reported in 2014

Recent changes and trends (reported in 2014)

Agriculture

  • There has been redistribution of land between 2000 and 2009, with the number of commercial holdings that are greater than 100 ha increasing from 19 to 23, while the overall number of commercial holdings has decreased from 206 to 179.
  • There has been a decrease in livestock numbers between 2000 and 2009. In 2009 there were 10,998 cattle (11,745 in 2000), 6,777 sheep (9,491 in 2000) and 247 pigs (13,420 in 2000).
  • The expansion of villages has resulted in loss of separate identity and gradual coalescence of settlements. There has been expansion of urban fringe into peri-urban around Hoylake and West Kirby. There has been significant development associated with the commercial sector at end of M56, and north-west of Willaston.
  • A wind farm has been constructed off the northern coast of the Wirral, with an application being considered for an extension. Pressure for additional development is likely to continue.

Boundary features

  • The estimated boundary length for the NCA is about 870 km. The total length of agreements between 1999 and 2003 is equivalent to about 2 per cent of this total. Between 1999 and 2003 Countryside Stewardship capital agreements for linear features included fencing (7 km), hedge management (4 km), hedge planting and restoration (5 km) and restored boundary protection (3 km).
  • In 2011 boundaries in Environmental Stewardship were ditches (13 km) hedgerows (277 km) stone walls (1 km) and woodlands (2 km).

Coast and rivers

  • The River Dee is an important source of drinking water for Wales and North West England. In 1999, the lower part of the Dee was designated as the UK’s first Water Protection Zone. The Dee and its tributaries are also renowned for their excellent fishing and there is an important cockle fishery in the estuary.
  • The health of the rivers, lakes, ground water and estuary in the Dee River Basin District has improved since the first river basin management plan was published in 2009. 28 per cent of water bodies were at ‘good’ status then and this has risen to 30 per cent in 2013 (Dee River Basin District: Challenges and choices – Summary of significant water management issues, Natural Resources Wales and Environment Agency, 2013)”.
  • The River Dee Restoration Project has assessed the condition of the Dee and proposes improvements to enhance river habitat. It has made recommendations for measures such as removal of modifications, to restore the water body to its near natural state.

Historic features

  • In 1918, about 2 per cent of the NCA was historic parkland. By 1995 it was estimated that 56 per cent of the 1918 area had been lost. About 28 per cent of the remaining parkland was covered by a Historic Parkland Grant.
  • About 85 per cent of historic farm buildings remained unconverted. Most were intact structurally.
  • Many historic field ponds, or ‘pits’ as they are often referred to locally, still remain as prominent features within the farmed landscape.

Minerals

  • Wirral is not a significant source of commercial minerals, with mineral activities historically limited to small quarries for local sandstone and winnable brick clay reserves. There are small reserves of winnable clay located at Carr Lane, Moreton. The restoration of these sites will have an ongoing influence on the character of the landscape. The Carr Lane, Moreton site has planning permission to extract clay to 2042.

Semi-natural habitats

  • The Dee Estuary has accreted and coastal salt marshes have developed, particularly on the English shoreline. The total extent of coastal salt marsh in the estuary has increased from 2,103 ha in 1983 to 2,832 ha in 2000. However, locally, on the Welsh shoreline, coastal salt marsh continues to erode, particularly between Greenfield and Flint.
  • In 2003, Countryside Stewardship agreements for enhancing existing lowland heathland covered 48 ha.

Settlement and development

  • The expansion of villages has resulted in loss of separate identity and gradual coalescence of settlements. There has been expansion of urban fringe into peri-urban around Hoylake and West Kirby. There has been significant development associated with the commercial sector at end of M56, and north-west of Willaston.
  • A wind farm has been constructed off the northern coast of the Wirral, with an application being considered for an extension. Pressure for additional development is likely to continue.

Trees and woodlands

  • Between 1999 and 2003 an area equivalent to 3 per cent of the 1999 total stock was approved for new planting under a Woodland Grant Scheme agreement (13 ha). Most planting is concentrated between Bebington and Heswall.
  • In 1999 about 4 per cent of the established eligible National Inventory of Woodland and Trees woodland stock was covered by a Woodland Grant Scheme management agreement. In 2003 the proportion of established, eligible National Inventory of Woodland and Trees woodland stock was about 2 per cent.
  • Open areas along the M53 corridor have seen extensive tree planting supported by the Forestry Commission and Groundwork Wirral.
  • There are 856 ha of woodland, although there has been 325 ha of deforestation and 292 ha of afforestation, giving a net loss of 33 ha of woodland.

Drivers of Change (reported in 2014)

Climate Change

  • Climate change projections indicate that the UK will experience hotter, drier summers and warmer, wetter winters. There could be an increase in the number of extreme weather events such as storm surges, intense rainfall and heat waves.
  • The North West Landscape Framework Climate Change Assessment assessed the exposure of this area and its natural assets to the impacts of climate change and its capacity to adapt (North West Landscape Framework – Climate Change Assessment, Natural England, 2010/2011). The low variation in topography across Wirral and gently undulating agricultural landscape make the area less likely to cope with climate change. Reduced summer rainfall could increase the drying of clay soils, leading to cracking and water stress, with consequential changes in agricultural practices to adapt to the changes.
  • Large tracts of lowland heathland occur on sandy hills in Wirral. Lowland heathland is sensitive to longer growing season, drought, and increased run-off, leading to changes in community composition, loss of bare ground areas, more heather beetle attacks, and increase in wildfires, which can destroy the seed bank. It is also vulnerable to competition from increased bracken growth due to warmer winters and a longer growing season. Lowland heathland regenerates but capacity depends on extent and nature of impact and soil conditions.
  • Sea level rise and coastal inundation due to storm events could affect the intertidal landscapes, particularly where they lie in front of coastal defences. Coastal salt marshes and intertidal mudflats (estuaries) are sensitive to tidal flooding as a result of rising sea levels and increased wave energy from storm surges. Coastal salt marsh is likely to experience coastal squeeze when it is trapped between rising sea levels and fixed defences, reducing adaptive capacity. They may also be sensitive to accelerated erosion of seaward marsh edge. This could result in loss of base of estuarine food webs and the loss of loafing and roosting sites for key bird species. Changes in internal creek patterns could affect internal erosion and sediment transport within the coastal salt marsh.
  • Coastal and flood plain grazing marsh is sensitive to flooding and inundation by the sea and saline intrusion leading to loss of fresh water marsh species. These habitats are sensitive to periods of drought leading to drying out and loss of habitat for breeding and feeding for wetland birds. Unpredictable inundation of coastal and flood plain grazing marsh with increased silt loading could lead to loss of botanical diversity if floods occur at different times of the year.
  • Coastal sand dunes are sensitive to erosion caused by sea level rise and increased wave energy leading to beach lowering. Change in shoreline position and dune system will impact on sand stability, dune mobility and groundwater levels affecting ecology.
  • Maritime cliffs and slopes are sensitive to erosion caused by increased rainfall which could result in more vertical slopes and more rapid retreat of coastal soft cliffs.

Other key drivers

  • The area faces challenges to accommodate future growth and new development, including reconciling economic development with the imperative of protecting its coastal distinctiveness and internationally important habitats.
  • There may be opportunities to develop wind, marine, solar and other renewable energy technologies, for example tidal and wind power. However, the Wirral coastline’s wildlife and habitats are of international importance and sensitive to development.
  • The coastline of this NCA is generally accreting, but at some unknown point rising sea levels are likely to alter this.
  • The network of green infrastructure provides opportunities for multifunctional green spaces, with multiple social, economic and environmental benefits. Green spaces can be managed in an integrated way that enhances the biodiversity, functionality, quality, connectivity and accessibility of the spaces. The Green Infrastructure Framework for North East Wales, Cheshire and the Wirral (Green Infrastructure Framework for North East Wales, Cheshire and Wirral, Mersey Dee Alliance, 2011) and Liverpool City Region Green Infrastructure Framework (Liverpool City Region and Warrington Green Infrastructure Framework Action Plan, The Mersey Forest, 2013) set out how a healthy natural environment can help sustain economic growth and thriving communities. Liverpool City Region Ecological Framework has been established and aims to reduce the loss of and/or fragmentation of important habitats (Liverpool City Region Ecological Framework).
  • Work has started on the England Coast Path, a new national trail around England’s open coast. This will enable rights of access along the coast and – where appropriate – ‘spreading room’. The trail will have an important future role for local recreation and tourism opportunities.
  • Ease of transport and improved communication technology have fuelled the desire to live in the countryside and the inland landscape with its mosaic of formal parkland, rural farmland and small villages is under pressure for expansion of existing settlement, ribbon development and in-fill expansion of villages, resulting in a loss of separate identity and gradual coalescence of urban areas.
  • Pressure from urban fringe development may include demand for recreation facilities such as equestrian riding schools (including enclosed exercise areas and associated large-scale buildings, horse grazing with associated changes to field boundaries and the use of informal animal shelters and sheds).
  • Changes in farming including diversification and changing patterns of land ownership. The purchase of agricultural holdings by non-farmers is a force for change, resulting in conversion of farm houses and farm buildings and changes in farm use. Changes in farm crops are possible, with an increase in areas under arable or fodder crops, a trend towards silage production, and possible moves towards biomass crops such as miscanthus.
  • The Mersey Forest Plan (Mersey Forest Plan, The Mersey Forest, 2014) covers part of this NCA, as well as a wider area and may direct change.
  • There may be risks posed by tree pests and diseases such as Chalara die-back of ash, which may impact upon wildlife, environmental quality and landscape.