National Character Area 158

Isles of Scilly - Landscape Change

Monitoring Landscape Change

Drivers for change
The Isles of Scilly comprise over 200 granite islands with a striking diversity of landscape and a varied coastline, with many rare and protected species at risk from particular factors. Rising sea levels increase the threat of saline creep and may affect coastal habitats, and increased storm intensity may impact archaeological features and island infrastructure. Pressures from increasing tourism and recreational pursuits threaten the tranquillity and rare habitats of the area, although recent schemes are in place to protect the overall sensitivity of the landscape.

Monitoring landscape change
The most recent monitoring of landscape change within NCAs forms part of the Environmental Improvement Plan Environmental Indicator Framework. This includes indicator G1: Changes in landscape and waterscape character, informed by indicator component G1a: Changes in the landscape characteristics of NCAs in England.

Indicator component G1a measures the extent to which landscape change is achieving the aspirational landscape outcomes described in the NCA Statements of Environmental Opportunity (SEOs). For this purpose, SEOs across all NCAs are distilled into 34 Super Landscape Objectives (SLOs).

NCAs with broadly similar character and pressures for change have been grouped into 18 sub-Agricultural Landscape Types (sub-ALTs) that represent rural, urban and coastal landscapes. Equal numbers of relevant SLOs were identified for monitoring within each sub-ALT and their associated NCAs. These SLOs were assessed based on changes between 2015 – 2023 (or the closest approximations to those dates with the data available). The results of each SLO were combined to form an integrated view of overall landscape change within each NCA during this time period.

For further details on this landscape monitoring, refer to the G1a Landscape Change Atlas and report, which are also available via the Landscape Change Evidence Hub.

Results of G1a: Changes in the landscape characteristics within this NCA
Displayed below is the result of the medium term change assessment which considers the changes in (simplified) overall trend categories for the two short term periods of 2015-2019 and 2019-2023.

This section includes:

  • the overall trend for this NCA for the short term change period 2019-2023
  • the 2019-2023 results of the underlying analysis for each of the individual Super Landscape Objectives considered relevant to the NCA; this includes the ‘provisional status’ (i.e. current understanding of state/condition) and the ‘change trend’ associated with each SLO.

Reporting of the 2015-2019 time period can be seen in the short term change results of G1a: Changes in the landscape characteristics within this NCA below.

Additional information on landscape change

Short term change results of G1a: Changes in the landscape characteristics within this NCA

Listed below are:

    • the overall trend for this NCA for short term change period 2015-2019
    • the results of the underlying analysis for each of the individual Super Landscape Objectives considered relevant to the NCA; this includes the “provisional status” (i.e. current understanding of state/condition) and the “change trend” associated with each SLO for short term change period 2015-2019.

The following SLOs are considered relevant to this NCA. The current provisional status of each objective and the assessment of change (expressed as a trend) is listed below. The overall integrated trend assessment is also listed.

2015 - 2019 change


Landscape change reported in 2014

Recent changes and trends (reported in 2014)

Agriculture

  • Agriculture on the islands has traditionally been a mix of bulbs/flowers, animals (beef and pigs) and vegetables. However, over the last 20 years flower breed development, mechanisation and growing techniques have led to the need for growers to specialise. This change has resulted in some land falling out of agricultural use and has led to a more intensive use on other sections.
  • Horticulture (flowers, vegetables) is still an important land use. Over the last five years cattle, hardy breeds such as Red Devons have been re-introduced to restore important conservation habitats and to help manage the necessary fallow period in the bulb rotation. This reduces reliance on chemicals. The introduction of grazing animals also provides a source of locally produced meat.

Boundary features

  • Tall green Hottentot fig boundaries (locally known as fences) are a significant landscape feature sheltering the small fields of bulbs and vegetables. Replanting of these has occurred because of loss due to frost and inclement weather. New fences are planted to sub-divide and create new flower fields. Higher Level Stewardship has enabled management of boundary features, in particular hedges and walls allowing their repair, replacement and maintenance.
  • The Pushing the Boundaries Project, commissioned by the Isles of Scilly Area of Outstanding Natural Beauty (AONB) Partnership, included an assessment of the historic significance of traditional stone field boundaries in Scilly. This historic environment survey recorded the current condition of the walls and prioritised those for future repair or restoration work.

Coast and rivers

  • Evolution of the shoreline is usually gradual but occasionally rapid and dramatic. This dynamic change often represents the greatest threat to coastal communities. St Mary’s, particularly Hugh Town, is extremely vulnerable to waves overtopping existing defences and quaysides. There is a particularly high likelihood of inundation during storm surges due to its Atlantic facing location and its construction on a low-lying area. This is becoming a more regular occurrence over the last 20 years. Increased storminess also affects vegetation by providing salt burn on a wide number of salt intolerant species.
  • Rising sea levels are increasingly threatening the fresh water supply through saline creep and direct contamination on St Mary’s and on the off islands through saline creep. A continuous ‘hold the line policy’ is in place around Hugh Town harbour, however the overall intent of the Shoreline Management Plan is a significant adaptation of the entire Hugh Town settlement in the longer term due to sea level rise and climate change impacts.

Historic features

  • The Island of Samson is a scheduled landscape to protect and conserve its complex historic environment. This brings greater protection to the landscapes of this important uninhabited island.
  • Some of Scillies’ Historic Monuments appear on the Historic Monuments ‘at risk register’ citing a variety of reasons for inclusion including erosion invasive vegetation, dumping and neglect.
  • Historic features are considered for protection, consolidation and repair through Higher Level Stewardship and the historic use and importance is reflected in planning decisions through the materials to be used or the size of an addition to a building.

Minerals

No information available.

Semi-natural habitats

  • The islands’ seabirds and their terrestrial habitats are designated as a Ramsar site making them of international importance. This is supported by the designation in 1996 of Isles of Scilly Special Protection Area (SPA). Since the designation of these sites for seabirds, the populations have declined by 24 per cent. This is due, in part, to decline in food availability and predation at nest sites by rats. The seas around Scilly are designated as a Marine Special Area of Conservation (SAC) and a Marine Conservation Zone (MCZ).
  • Forty-nine per cent of the SSSI are in a favourable condition with the remaining 51 per cent described as unfavourable recovering. This will mean that many of the sites are improving in condition some through the re- introduction of appropriate management including the re-introduction of cutting and grazing regimes.

Settlement and development

  • Recent development on the islands has focused on the improvement of island infrastructure such as the Porth Cressa regeneration project in Hugh Town, the New 5 Islands School the mixed-use development of Abbey Farm Tresco, and the proposed enlargement of the Quay in St Mary’s.
  • There is no open market housing development on the islands and occupancy restrictions apply to any new dwellings. These focus on key workers that provide vital services to the islands. There is acute pressure to provide housing for local key workers and suitable areas are identified in the Local Plan.

Trees and woodlands

  • Trees are not common on the Isles of Scilly due to shallow soils, salt and water- laden winds. However, Monterey pine and cypress act as shelterbelts for the gardens on Tresco and for some agricultural land on St Mary’s. These are replaced with young specimens as the older trees die or become unstable due to wind blow. This changes the landscape significantly, opening up different views.
  • Unlike much of the mainland, English elms continue to thrive on the islands with magnificent examples and elm copses present on St Mary’s. Dutch elm disease has never been recorded on the islands. Some of these areas of woodland have been brought into management over the last 10 years to enhance their biodiversity and structure.
  • Woodland cover currently accounts for 3 per cent of the NCA. No new planting schemes are proposed which is in keeping with landscape character.

Drivers of Change (reported in 2014)

Climate Change

  • Potential sea level rise would impact the islands infrastructure by affecting the road network and in particular, the main link between the airport and the Quayside in St Mary’s. Sea level rise will also impact on the coastal habitats including the sand dune systems.
  • A temperature increase may change the diversity of the islands’ ecosystems through the increase in some species more tolerant of a warmer climate and the loss of those that are unable to adapt. This is also likely within the marine environment with increases in Mediterranean species. These changes may also provide increased localised food sources for the islands’ nesting sea birds.
  • Increased storm intensity will erode coastal habitats, archaeological features and island infrastructure. Increased wave energy will speed the erosion of landscape features, such as the granite outcrops (which will still remain slow in general terms) and impact on the vegetated fences and small woodlands of the islands.
  • Potential changes in rainfall intensity and pattern will affect the type of crops grown, for example drought-tolerant varieties. This combined with reductions in chemical use, due to the increase cost associated with importing it, may lead to landscape change.
  • Increased drought conditions will put further pressure on the islands’ water supply and the need to increase the reliance on desalinised seawater.

Other key drivers

  • Pressure to develop the islands is low; however, attention needs to be applied to ensure that any enhancements consider the overall sensitivity of the landscape and the natural environment.
  • There is a need to ensure agriculture retains an important role in the islands’ economy while continuing to include the management of unimproved and semi-improved habitats as part of the islands’ agricultural system.
  • The natural environment has an important role to play in the continued economic prosperity of the islands, as it is the main reason that people visit them.
  • Manage appropriately that land on the off islands that provides the important nesting sites for sea bird populations.