National Character Area 29
Howardian Hills - Description
Physical and functional links to other National Character Areas
The Howardian Hills are physically distinct and, to some extent, separated from neighbouring areas: their Jurassic limestones and sandstones are relatively resistant to erosion compared with the marls, shales and clays of the surrounding vales. Nonetheless, the hills are linked – both visually and physically – by their pattern of rivers and watercourses. The majority of watercourses that rise in the hills of this NCA drain in a broadly eastward direction, into the River Derwent: some joining further upstream, with the River Rye, while others meet the Derwent further south, in the Vale of York NCA. The River Derwent rises in the Vale of Pickering, flowing down through Kirkham Gorge and through the Howardian Hills before flowing southwards into the Vale of York NCA, and from there towards the Humber estuary. The Derwent is the only major watercourse in the NCA. In the north of the area there is also a small stretch of the River Rye (a tributary of the Derwent).
There are strong visual links to and from this NCA across the lower-lying land of the Vale of Pickering to the east and the Vale of York to the west, and northwards to the elevated land mass of the North York Moors.
The only significant transport corridor within the Howardian Hills NCA, and linking it with surrounding areas, is the A64 in the south-east. Otherwise, this very rural NCA is served by a network of minor roads, and is characterised by very high levels of tranquillity and low levels of intrusion.
The Howardian Hills today
The Howardian Hills comprise a belt of complex irregular limestone and sandstone ridges and valleys, rising above the surrounding vales of adjacent NCAs, with prominent scarp faces on the outermost ridges. It is thus physically very distinct and separate from the surrounding areas. The landscape is a diverse mosaic of sheltered valleys, woodland, historic buildings, parkland and villages, with open arable, pasture and large-scale plantations on the intervening ridges and plateaux. This rich mosaic and unspoilt nature create the area’s special character: Three-quarters of the NCA has been designated as the Howardian Hills AONB and 3 per cent of the NCA area lies within the southern edge of the North York Moors National Park Authority area.
Woodland is a significant element of the overall character of the NCA, covering 15 per cent of the land area and occurring throughout. It has been described as forming a ‘green web’ across the landscape, and is one of this NCA’s most significant unifying features. Over half of the woodland cover is thought to be ancient in origin (that is, dating from before 1600), but only 16 per cent of this retains its native woodland character – predominantly pedunculate oak woods, with ash on the steeper slopes. The rest has been overplanted, often with conifer species – European larch, Scots pine, Norway spruce and others. Woodland cover often accentuates the NCA’s landform of ridges and steep slopes. Many of the woodlands are small, although there are some large commercial plantations, such as at Yearsley Moor. The habitat mosaic supports farmland bird assemblages, including tree sparrow and grey partridge.
Wood pasture and veteran trees are important features of the extensive designed landscapes and parklands associated with grand country houses, and are a key element of the woodland network across the NCA. In the 20th century areas of heathland and rough upland pasture were converted to agriculture, so that little now remains other than on rides within plantation woodland. This is an area of mixed farming, with arable cropping predominant.
The effects of the last glaciations left a particularly dramatic mark on the landscape of this area, creating a classic example of modified drainage. Prior to the last ice age, the natural drainage of the wider area was from west to east – along the Vale of Pickering, which lies between the uplands of the North York Moors and those of the Howardian Hills and Yorkshire Wolds. During the last glaciation, this natural flow was dammed by the North Sea ice sheet to the east and a finger of the Pennine ice sheet to the west, causing water to collect in the Vale of Pickering (which at the time became Lake Pickering), and eventually to overtop and outflow at its southern end, at Kirkham Gorge. Today the River Derwent enters the NCA from the north, flowing southwards through the deeply incised Kirkham Gorge, on the eastern edge of the area. The Derwent is the main watercourse within the NCA; minor watercourses arising within the Howardian Hills shed predominantly into the Derwent or its tributaries. The Derwent is afforded national and international importance for its wildlife, including river fish species whose ancestors migrated from the Rhine and other European rivers in the early post-glacial period, when the North Sea was a freshwater lake.
Wetlands – particularly fens, marshes and alder woodlands – associated with the Derwent flood plain and with other minor watercourses (such as at Dalby Bush Fen), represent some of the area’s most important habitats. Similarly, wetland areas – such as those in the distinct low-lying Coxwold-Gilling Gap in the north – provide an important habitat for breeding lapwing, curlew and snipe. Much semi-natural grassland habitat has been lost to agricultural improvement, although remnants persist on steeper slopes, such as the limestone grassland at Caulkleys Bank, and the hay meadows interspersed within the arable landscape – the largest concentration being in the Derwent valley. The AONB is noted for the parasitic plant knapweed broomrape, a local rarity. Verges alongside roads and tracks, as well as churchyards, provide other semi-natural habitat within the wider ecological network, increasing the permeability of this landscape.
Settlement consists mainly of small villages and isolated farmsteads, scattered throughout but predominantly found on ridgetops or valley-side spring line locations. Many of the nucleated valley settlements are medieval in origin. Settlements such as Hovingham, Slingsby and Malton are served by a network of minor roads similarly related to the topography, the only main roads being the A64 between York and Scarborough, and the B1363 and B1257. The area has a high proportion of vernacular buildings, created using diverse materials sourced from many former small-scale quarries. Traditional farmsteads tend to be large in scale and built from either limestone or sandstone, with red pantile roofs. They relate to the area’s arable farming economy, and the importance of the rearing and fattening of livestock in yards. The overall field pattern tends to be fields of mixed size, mainly enclosed by hedgerows, but with some drystone walls on the raised plateaux. Parish and field patterns are pre-enclosure in origin around farmsteads and villages, overlain by later Parliamentary enclosure. Where linear strip fields survive, these tend to be in the immediate vicinity of settlements. Where well-drained soils have formed over limestone between Malton and Hovingham, grade 2 agricultural land allows intensive arable cultivation, with large fields and fewer boundary trees. Elsewhere, grade 3 land supports arable and livestock farming.
The landscape today continues to be influenced by features from the area’s past: prominent bronze-age burial mounds and iron-age earthworks circle upper hillsides, and there are many fine examples of churches from the late Saxon and early Norman period – although most are medieval in origin. Particularly characteristic of this NCA are the number and quality of designed historic parklands and landscapes, the most important being Castle Howard, after which the NCA is named. Castle Howard was built mostly between 1699 and 1712, for the 3rd Earl of Carlisle, to a design by Sir John Vanbrugh. The house and estate originally extended over 5,000 hectares, incorporating notable architectural and landscape features such as the Great Lake (which, at 280,000 m2, is the largest waterbody in the NCA). The influence of the Castle Howard extends beyond its boundaries, in the vistas that have been opened up through the surrounding countryside. Other notable historic parklands include Newburgh Priory, Hovingham Hall, Whitwell Hall and Nunnington Hall. Throughout the NCA are numerous smaller parklands, including Crayke Castle, Gilling Castle, Howsham Hall, Hutton Hall, Wiganthorpe Hall, Swinton Grange, Hildenley and Brandsby Hall. The protection and maintenance of these landscapes is essential to maintaining the historic significance and character of the area, and the special character of the AONB.
Recreational activity is largely concentrated around the highly popular formal attractions of Castle Howard, Kirkham Priory and other historic buildings. The attractive villages and network of footpaths support more dispersed recreational activity within the area, which is notable for its high levels of tranquillity and low levels of intrusion.
The landscape through time
The Howardian Hills are formed from Middle Jurassic sandstones and mudstones created by inbraided rivers about 165 million years ago, and by Upper Jurassic limestones and calcareous sandstones deposited a few million years later, when shallow tropical seas submerged the land. Numerous east- west faults cross the Howardian Hills and contribute to the irregular ridges and valleys, which give rise to a generally rolling and hummocky landform. Among these east-west aligned faults is the Coxwold-Gilling rift, which forms the valley (known as the Coxwold-Gilling Gap) separating the Howardian Hills from the main Jurassic block of the Hambleton Hills to the north. These faults also influence the sudden changes in soil condition, other factors being superficial deposits, topography and hydrology. Although this is a prominent belt of hills, the maximum elevation is only some 170 m. Prominent scarps of limestone are a notable feature along the outermost ridges, where the land drops down to the Vales of York and Pickering.
Although the area was not covered by glaciers in the last glacial period, the effects of glaciation have nevertheless had a dramatic effect in altering drainage patterns. The natural drainage of the Vale of Pickering, which lies north of the Howardian Hills, was blocked by the North Sea ice sheet to the east and by the Pennine ice sheet, which occupied the Vale of York, to the west. These created a large dammed lake, which found an outlet to the south-west, cutting through the rocks to form the deeply-incised Kirkham Gorge. The course of the River Derwent was thus naturally and permanently diverted, to flow south through the Howardian Hills to the Ouse basin. Glacial drift deposits from the retreating Vale of York ice sheet have also left their mark, with a more undulating landform to the south and west of the area.
Early human activity dating from the Mesolithic and Neolithic periods is widely represented in the discovery of stone tools and flint scatters. The earliest signs of human habitation date from the Neolithic period: evidence of ritual burial sites indicates some organisation of the population. By the Bronze Age, tree clearance was making space for agriculture as population increased; it is likely that by the end of the Bronze Age much of the forest had been cleared, enabling moorland habitats to develop. The most striking feature dating from the Bronze Age is the system of banks and ditches that run along the edges of prominent hills for several hundred metres, for example above Slingsby Heights and Barton Heights. The early pattern of settlement on fertile land continued through the Iron Age, and there is extensive and well preserved evidence of both enclosed and unenclosed farmsteads, with round houses and field systems. When the Romans arrived, they discovered an organised agrarian society, with established arable and pastoral farming. They established the fort at Malton, and a pottery industry at Crambeck, supplying northern England with grey tableware, and left behind a complex landholding and administrative system.
Many of the place names in the Howardian Hills have Anglo-Saxon roots, such as Hovingham and Gilling. Later Viking influence is also indicated, for example Skewsby and Ganthorpe. From the 9th century, a period of landscape change began – associated with the development of villages, open field systems and estates. Many villages were planned in linear form, probably in the 12th and 13th centuries, and there is a high concentration of deserted medieval settlements, marking contraction from the early 14th century. Castles and priories (such as pre-Dissolution Newburgh and Kirkham Priories) were dominant in the landscape from this time, with country houses, estates and parkland developing later. The latter, with their associated estate villages, are a major aspect of today’s landscape character – examples are Castle Howard, Newburgh Priory and Hovingham Hall. The establishment of country houses by the aristocracy, mainly in the 18th century, with an emphasis on controlling, designing and remodelling the natural world for picturesque effect, led to particularly widespread change in the character of the landscape. Most significant of these country houses is Castle Howard. Popular features included long, formal avenues of trees leading to the house or main entrance, lakes created by damming small valleys, and walks laid out through woods and across fields, their routes designed to give glimpses of the house, long-distance views over the countryside, and views of features such as bridges and follies. This type of building style substantially altered the agricultural landscape, removing some villages and creating new estate villages, making for a planned, rural landscape. Estates were also responsible for the planting of blocks of woodland, including copses for field sports.
The enclosure of fields between the 17th and 19th centuries created the regular rectilinear pattern that remains a characteristic feature of today’s landscape. The 20th century saw further landscape change, as heathland and rough upland pastures were converted to productive agriculture or planted with conifers (typically European larch, Scots pine and Norway spruce). Little of this semi-natural upland habitat now remains. The agricultural landscape has been substantially altered by the trend in the latter half of the 20th century for field enlargement, increased mechanisation, and conversion of pasture and less improved ground into more intensive arable farming. The colours and textures of the farmed landscape have changed as oilseed rape increases, and rough grazing land is reduced. Intensive pig and poultry farming have increased, smaller estates and parklands have been lost to modern agriculture, and substantial areas of remnant ancient woodland have been overplanted with commercial conifer species.
It is notable that the industrial expansion of the 19th century made little impact on the character of this landscape. The greatest evidence of its historic use dates from prehistory to the medieval period, and from the later development of grand country houses, with their formal designed landscapes.
In recent decades there has not been the pressure, faced in other parts of the country, for major new development in the Howardian Hills. However, a major upgrade of the A64 trunk road has been mooted, and there are existing small-scale quarries and proposals for oil and gas exploration. Arguably, greater change is occurring through the gradual erosion of character brought about by the cumulative effect of small-scale changes in building styles and materials, and by the introduction of street lighting into areas hitherto characterised by dark night skies and low intrusion.
The scenic value of the area was recognised in its designation by the Countryside Commission in 1986 as an AONB. Under the Countryside and Rights of Way Act 2000, North Yorkshire County Council, along with Ryedale and Hambleton District Councils, are required, jointly, to prepare and publish a management plan, reviewed every five years, for how they will manage these landscape changes within the AONB, while ensuring that its special qualities are protected.






