National Character Area 9
Eden Valley - Description
Physical and functional links to other National Character Areas
The Eden Valley National Character Area (NCA) in north-east Cumbria encompasses the broad valleys of the River Eden and its tributaries, most notably the Petteril, with the wider Eden catchment extending into neighbouring NCAs. The Eden is a wide south-north orientated valley, located between the scarp of the North Pennines NCA to the east, the rugged Orton Fells NCA and Cumbria High Fells NCA to the west, and the Solway Basin NCA to the north. The valley stretches from the village of Brough in the south, northwards via Appleby-in-Westmorland and Penrith, to the fringes of Carlisle. It includes a small part of the North Pennines Area of Outstanding Natural Beauty.
The soft lowland landscape of this NCA contrasts markedly with surrounding rugged upland landscapes as the improved agricultural land of the valley yields to the semi-improved grasslands of the steep slopes. The land use in the valley developed in close association with these upland areas, with many farms in the Eden Valley sending livestock to graze on their commons in the summer months, and upland stock overwintering in the valley. The valley provides a strongly contrasting setting to these uplands and is visible from them – the visual relationship between the North Pennines escarpment and the Eden Valley is particularly strong. To the north, the boundary is not as easily defined on the ground where the NCA merges into the coastal plain around Carlisle and the Solway Basin.
The drainage and orientation of the Eden Valley are north-westerly, towards the Solway Basin. The linear nature of the NCA is defined by the River Eden which, originating in the Yorkshire Dales, links the Eden Valley to surrounding NCAs. The Eden drains half the county of Cumbria and is fed by rivers originating in the uplands of the Orton Fells, Cumbrian High Fells and North Pennines and flows into the Solway Firth through the Solway Basin NCA. Severe flooding events experienced downstream in Carlisle, thus have their origins upstream. The high-quality environment of the River Eden forms an important aquatic corridor through Cumbria, encompassing extensive semi-natural habitats along its route.
The Eden Valley is an important transport corridor through this predominantly upland region. The M6 motorway and West Coast Main Line railway run through the western edge of the NCA from Carlisle to Penrith, a strategic link between Scotland and England. The A66 provides a link westward to the Cumbria High Fells NCA and southeast to the North Pennines NCA and Yorkshire Dales NCA. In the north-east of the area, the A69 leads to the head of the Tyne Valley and the Border Moors and Forests NCA.
The Eden Valley today
The Eden Valley is a gently undulating, lowland agricultural landscape which contrasts markedly with the scarp face of the North Pennines to the east, the Orton Fells to the south and the rugged upland fells of the Lake District to the west. The undulating landform is largely the result of material deposited at the end of the last ice age, moulded into the characteristic mounds of drumlins and eskers, this glacial material giving rise to fertile soils. The valley is characterised by an intimate blend of undulating mixed farmland with significant areas of woodland, farm copses, mature hedgerow trees, stone walls and historic villages, giving a sense of shelter and containment, enhanced by the juxtaposition with its ‘wilder’ upland neighbours.
The fast-flowing River Eden, of European importance for its habitats and wildlife, rises at Hell Gill in the Yorkshire Dales. The Eden supports a diverse aquatic flora, Atlantic salmon, bullhead, lampreys and white-clawed crayfish, among its many features of interest. This important wildlife resource is recognised in the river being designated a Special Area of Conservation (SAC) along its course through the NCA. The River Eden flows through an ecologically rich and varied landscape corridor including small but important areas of semi-natural riparian willow and alder woodland and flood plain pastures; however, sections of the River Eden SAC are characterised by modifications, straightened and bounded by hard engineering. The rare river jelly lichen is found on the banks of the Eden, there are important whooper swan and sand martin populations, otters are also found, and the gravel exposures within the river are important habitat for exposed river sediment invertebrates.
The convergence of the rivers and streams within the Eden Valley, drained from the surrounding uplands, creates the potential for severe flooding events. Much of the flooding is of the farmed flood plain; however, Carlisle and Appleby-in- Westmorland have flooded regularly in recent years, and Appleby has its own flood defence system.
The river narrows to a gorge where it cuts through an isolated sandstone ridge north of Kirkoswald and at Wetheral and Armathwaite. The Cleveland- Armathwaite Dyke forms a chain of low, linear hills and a natural weir on the River Eden at Armathwaite – supporting oak, birch and ash hanger woodlands. Here, the rich red of the exposed sandstone creates visual unity with the sandstone built villages and other stone features such as walls and gateposts. The Eden is joined by many tributary streams and gills from the surrounding higher ground, their courses marked by bands of broadleaved woodland, including the ash dominated limestone woodlands of the Pennine foothills, contributing to the landscape’s well-wooded appearance.
Blocks of conifers, regular in shape, have been planted on the sandstone ridge between the rivers Eden and Petteril and the eastern foothills of the Pennine escarpment, some over 100 ha in size. Managed farm and estate woodlands, consisting of both broadleaved (including ancient woodland and ancient replanted woodland) and coniferous trees, occupy large blocks of the broader valley floor. Small copses and shelterbelts are frequent and have often been planted beside farmsteads or as game cover for shooting interests. Remnant stands of black poplar – rare in northern England – are also found in places. The NCA is an important managed red squirrel stronghold, and the upper Eden Valley is an important area for black grouse, berry-producing scrub woodland being a vital part of their ecology.
The majority of the land is pasture with significant coverage of arable crops on the richer soils associated with the better drained glacial landforms on the valley floor. Small farm fruit orchards are located within the valley and the area supports farmland birds such as grey partridge and tree sparrow. Mature hedgerows and drystone walls typically form the boundaries between the rectilinear, medium large patchwork of farmed fields. Towards the fringes of the area, particularly on the edges of the main settlements, hedgerows become thinner and are replaced by fences, with pony paddocks a feature close to Carlisle.
The lowland heath in the Eden Valley is an important remnant of a once more extensive habitat, now persisting in fragments across the chain of low sandstone hills between the River Eden and River Petteril. The largest and best examples are at the Wan Fell and Lazonby Fell Sites of Special Scientific Interest (SSSI). Much of the original heath was planted up with conifers; however, a heath understory persists in places, and much of this has been brought into restoration management in recent years, supported through the Higher Level Stewardship scheme.
The Cumbrian Marsh Fritillary SAC consists of Skelton Pasture SSSI and an area of Middlesceugh Woods and Pastures SSSI in the west of the NCA. The area has been designated for the marsh fritillary, although only Middlesceugh currently supports a population of this nationally declining butterfly, now extinct from much of its former range and confined to western and northern parts of the UK. The larval food plant, Devil’s-bit scabious, occurs in the mosaic of damp purple moor-grass and scrub habitat. The Eden Valley’s population and those of Bassenthwaite moss at River Derwent and Bassenthwaite Lake SAC comprise a north-western set of populations which are genetically different from the other English populations.
Semi-natural habitat in the Eden Valley tends to be small and fragmented, with the notable exception of woodlands associated with the River Eden and the heath of the sandstone ridge. Basin mires in the Eden Valley are scattered, mostly between Appleby-in-Westmorland and Penrith and to the east of Carlisle, typically formed in kettle holes within the undulating topography of drift deposits. These wetland sites are fragmented and small, having been affected by past management, predominantly peat cutting or drainage. They are seasonally inundated and used by wintering wildfowl and waders, for example golden plover and lapwing. From autumn to spring, large flocks of lapwing feed on the arable fields between Penrith and Appleby. The Solway Firth’s tidal influence on the River Eden impacts on the way in which these and other birds use the valley’s habitats for feeding and roosting.
Much of the grassland in the Eden Valley has historically been improved for agriculture, which has led to the loss of riparian habitats and species-rich grassland and associated fauna. The Skelton-Penrith-Lamonby area and Orton fringes between Kirkby Stephen and Penrith still have wide, species-rich road verges and fields with hay meadow communities; however, elsewhere these habitats are isolated and fragmented, in small fields or verges and on the steep banks of the Eden and its tributaries. The scarp foot slopes in the east form a transitional zone between the Eden Valley and the North Pennines, with unimproved acid and neutral grassland, patches of heath habitat and geometric blocks of coniferous plantation imparting a more upland character in this part of the NCA.
The historic settlement pattern of stone-built nucleated and linear villages with substantial churches, village greens and scattered farmsteads is a key element of the Eden Valley’s landscape character. Penrith, Appleby-in-Westmorland and Kirkby Stephen (on the fringe of the NCA) are the main market towns serving this largely agricultural community. Earthworks of early settlements and linked field systems are common across the landscape, reflecting the contraction of villages since medieval times. A number of villages were established in the valley bottom in association with the river, while others have developed along the springline of the North Pennines fellside. Red sandstone is the dominant building material of the Eden Valley, with limestone used on the margins of the area reflecting the underlying geology, for example at Appleby (due to the proximity of the Orton Fells) and along the footslopes of the North Pennines.
The Eden Valley has experienced significant surface quarrying and mining of gypsum, for use in the plaster and plasterboard industry, and used in its anhydrated form in the production of Portland cement. Historically this was the basis of a number of local companies, working as early as 1790 at Acorn Bank, and eventually forming one of the largest manufacturing organisations in the world, British Gypsum. This mineral extraction was strongly linked to the development of the local transport network. There was also significant working at Little Salkeld where the villages benefited from the development of these quarries. Today, gypsum working in the Eden Valley is confined to the Kirkby Thore area, feeding the plant which also processes gypsum from around the world.
The valley provides an important transport corridor through this otherwise upland region: the West Coast Main Line railway, M6 motorway and A66 trunk road intersect the area, supplementing a network of rural roads bounded by walls, hedgerows and mature trees. The valley also provides much of the route for the Settle to Carlisle Railway, which provides significant visitor interest within the NCA and with it support for the local economy.
The landscape through time
The underlying bedrock of the NCA is dominated by sandstones from the Permo-Triassic Period, the oldest being the more resistant Penrith Sandstone which forms a prominent ridge within the broad valley landscape. These sandstones were deposited as a series of large, windblown dunes in a desert which covered the area during the Permo-Triassic Period.
The Pennine escarpment to the east of the NCA was formed by movement along the Pennine Fault, and is composed of Carboniferous rocks, mainly limestone. Mudstones and volcanic rocks of Ordovician age crop out along the foot of the scarp, with erosion producing striking conical hills such as Knock Pike. These eastern foothills give rise to a mosaic of unimproved acid and neutral grassland with woodland and small areas of lowland heath. The 60-million-year-old Cleveland-Armathwaite Dyke igneous intrusion cuts across the NCA from east to west, forming a low linear feature and a natural weir across the River Eden south of Armathwaite.
The relatively soft rocks of the Eden Valley had been eroded to a low relief before the onset of glaciation; nonetheless, the action of ice sheets which subsequently moved across the area has substantially influenced the physical landscape and land use of today. The ice sheets deposited a thick layer of glacial debris, worked into features such as drumlins during the process of deposition. The distinctive, softly rounded drumlins occur across large areas – for example around Warwick, Wetheral, Hayton and Brampton – and there are extensive deposits of sand and gravel. The glacial till has given rise to rich, fertile soils supporting some of the best agricultural land in Cumbria. In some locations, overdeepened hollows or ‘kettle holes’, left in the ice’s retreat, developed into small basin mires, some of which are of considerable ecological interest although isolated within the landscape. The sand and gravels have been extracted in recent decades, leaving a legacy in the landscape of sites which, although restored, are now open and treeless.
The dull salmon pink sandstone, sparkling with high quartz content, has long been used as a building material, along with the St Bees Sandstone also found in the area. The poor sandy soils associated with the sandstone ridge support patches of heathland, poorly drained neutral grassland and plantation conifer blocks. This geodiversity is reflected in the predominant local building materials of stone and slate.
The fertile soils and relative shelter afforded by the valley’s topography have long created favourable conditions for agriculture. The Eden Valley has a long history of human occupation dating back to prehistoric times – the flint tools of Mesolithic and Neolithic people have been found across the valley. Some of the most significant Neolithic monuments include Long Meg and Her Daughters stone circle near Little Salkeld, and the henges of Mayburgh and King Arthur’s Round Table at Eamont Bridge, with the latter suggesting later links with Arthurian legend. Eamont Bridge stands on the former boundary of Cumberland and Westmorland, and probably also stood on the 10th-century border between the emerging kingdoms of England and Scotland.
Numerous forts and marching camps, including Voreda, were constructed along the route of the main Roman road from Carlisle to Penrith, and then eastwards to Brough, attesting to the valley’s importance, to this day, as a transport corridor. The medieval castles at Brougham and Brough, now ruins, were built on the sites of Roman forts, with the medieval castle and town of Appleby-in-Westmorland between them, demonstrating the longstanding strategic importance of the valley.
The Eden Valley has very strong associations with the redoubtable Lady Anne Clifford, Countess of Pembroke, Dorset and Montgomery (1590-1676), long famed for her determined legal battle to inherit her extensive family estates. She eventually owned, restored and regularly travelled between, a string of castles along the Eden valley and on into the Yorkshire, including Brough, Brougham and Appleby, as well as building almshouses and restoring local churches. She is buried in Appleby church, and is commemorated in Lady Anne’s Way, a long distance walking route which runs from her castle at Skipton, through the Eden valley to Penrith.
The productive soils and gentle slopes of the Eden Valley have been extensively farmed and ‘improved’ over centuries, leaving only small areas of less intensively managed rough ground on the Penrith ridge and Pennine fringe to the east. The pattern of agriculture, like that of settlement, is more akin to the lowland Midlands than the adjacent uplands of Cumbria and the Pennines: an increase of pasture and grazing over arable from the 14th century, then a concentration on livestock fattened for slaughter and growing corn began to outweigh dairying and grazing in the late 18th century, resulting in a proliferation of farm buildings and yards to house stock and to store and process cereals.
Many villages developed at the foot of the Pennine scarp were part of extensive estates that stretched from the lowland vales to the upper fells, used for seasonal livestock grazing, and this pattern remains broadly intact today. Other settlements developed adjacent to or in association with the river itself. Many of the smaller settlements have contracted since medieval times, and the earthworks of early settlements are common in the landscape. The market towns of Penrith and Appleby-in-Westmorland grew significantly from the 18th century, to become, along with the city of Carlisle, the dominant settlements today. The landscape of parts of the Eden Valley, particularly the sections of wooded gorge between Wetheral and Staffield, has attracted tourists since Victorian times, although the neighbouring uplands, which include protected landscapes of national importance, remain the principal destination of tourists to the wider area. The Eden Valley itself remains an important recreational resource for local people and the less mobile, and is well used, particularly at weekends.
Over the past 70 years, evolution of this landscape has seen subtle changes in agricultural land use, with a consolidation of farm holdings, a general trend of conversion of permanent pasture to arable, though with some reversion of arable to grassland, and an increase in fenced boundaries with corresponding decline in hedgerows and stone walls and loss of landscape structure. Agri-environment scheme grants have reversed some of the loss of traditional boundary features. Grants for woodland management have encouraged an increase of woodland under active management in the area, with restructuring and regeneration of ancient woodland sites previously under plantations as well as new woodland creation, strengthening the landscape’s traditional wooded character.
Recent years have seen development on the edge of settlements, and an increase in traffic on the M6 motorway and A66 trunk road that run the length of the valley, with a corresponding decrease in the proportion of the NCA which is classed by the Campaign to Protect Rural England as ‘undisturbed’.






