National Character Area 148

Devon Redlands - Landscape Change

Monitoring Landscape Change

Drivers for change
The Devon Redlands has a strong character of ploughed fields, cliffs and exposures, with scattered farmsteads and villages creating a historic landscape that is vulnerable to increasing development pressures. Changes in agricultural practices may impact many managed habitats and dependent species, particularly grassland sites and hedgerows, and climate change may increase soil erosion and flooding. Increasing housing and infrastructure demand in Exeter as well as pressure to develop wind turbines in exposed areas also threaten to change the character of the landscape.

Monitoring landscape change
The most recent monitoring of landscape change within NCAs forms part of the Environmental Improvement Plan Environmental Indicator Framework. This includes indicator G1: Changes in landscape and waterscape character, informed by indicator component G1a: Changes in the landscape characteristics of NCAs in England.

Indicator component G1a measures the extent to which landscape change is achieving the aspirational landscape outcomes described in the NCA Statements of Environmental Opportunity (SEOs). For this purpose, SEOs across all NCAs are distilled into 34 Super Landscape Objectives (SLOs).

NCAs with broadly similar character and pressures for change have been grouped into 18 sub-Agricultural Landscape Types (sub-ALTs) that represent rural, urban and coastal landscapes. Equal numbers of relevant SLOs were identified for monitoring within each sub-ALT and their associated NCAs. These SLOs were assessed based on changes between 2015 – 2023 (or the closest approximations to those dates with the data available). The results of each SLO were combined to form an integrated view of overall landscape change within each NCA during this time period.

For further details on this landscape monitoring, refer to the G1a Landscape Change Atlas and report, which are also available via the Landscape Change Evidence Hub.

Results of G1a: Changes in the landscape characteristics within this NCA
Displayed below is the result of the medium term change assessment which considers the changes in (simplified) overall trend categories for the two short term periods of 2015-2019 and 2019-2023.

This section includes:

  • the overall trend for this NCA for the short term change period 2019-2023
  • the 2019-2023 results of the underlying analysis for each of the individual Super Landscape Objectives considered relevant to the NCA; this includes the ‘provisional status’ (i.e. current understanding of state/condition) and the ‘change trend’ associated with each SLO.

Reporting of the 2015-2019 time period can be seen in the short term change results of G1a: Changes in the landscape characteristics within this NCA below.

Additional information on landscape change

Short term change results of G1a: Changes in the landscape characteristics within this NCA

Listed below are:

    • the overall trend for this NCA for short term change period 2015-2019
    • the results of the underlying analysis for each of the individual Super Landscape Objectives considered relevant to the NCA; this includes the “provisional status” (i.e. current understanding of state/condition) and the “change trend” associated with each SLO for short term change period 2015-2019.

The following SLOs are considered relevant to this NCA. The current provisional status of each objective and the assessment of change (expressed as a trend) is listed below. The overall integrated trend assessment is also listed.

2015 - 2019 change


Landscape change reported in 2014

Recent changes and trends (reported in 2014)

Agriculture

  • Countryside Quality Counts data for the period from 1999 – 2003 shows Countryside Stewardship uptake for annual area features to be consistently above national average.
  • The predominant land use is grassland, with approximately half of all farm holdings classified as livestock in terms of their farming type. However, between 2000 and 2009 there was an increase in the number of arable and horticultural holdings, 14% in number, and a decrease in the number of all other farming types, possibly in response to market prices.
  • There was a 15 per cent increase in farm holdings over 100 ha between 2000 and 2009 (58 per cent of the farmed area) and all holdings of less than 100 ha size declined in number by around 10 per cent.

Boundary features

  • Evidence from Countryside Quality Counts for the period from 1999 – 2003 suggests that boundary features have probably been neglected. Between 1999-2003 Countryside Stewardship capital agreements for linear features included fencing (88 km), hedge management (38 km), hedge planting and restoration (88 km) and restored boundary protection (107 km). The estimated boundary length for the NCA is about 8,426 km, the total length of boundaries under agreement, between 1999 and 2003, was equivalent to about 4 per cent of this total.
  • The need for hedgerows for stock management is likely to have declined in recent years with the decline in dairy and mixed agriculture and increase in cereal production and horticulture. An increase in cereal cultivation has also resulted in larger fields, particularly on the valley floors and some larger or double gateways.

Coast and rivers

  • Storm surges, coupled with high tides have led to a higher incidence of flooding, particularly of the railway line and coastal properties near Dawlish.

Historic features

  • In 1918 about 4 per cent of the NCA was historic parkland. By 1995 it is estimated that 45 per cent of the 1918 area had been lost. About 51 per cent of the remaining parkland is covered by an Historic Parkland Grant, and 29 per cent is included in an agri-environmental scheme. Thus opportunities for managing this important aspect of the historic landscape remain. It should also be noted that about 64% of historic farm buildings remain unconverted. About 96% are intact structurally.
  • Remnant traditional orchards are scattered across the NCA, providing significant cultural associations in some neighbourhoods, for example around Whimple. Many orchards are now under environmental stewardship.

Minerals

  • Restoration of the Black Hill Quarry on the edge of the the Pebblebed heaths is now complete; however the site is still used as a storage area and processing plant for sands and gravels transported from Venn Ottery and Marshbroadmoor. The site is within the East Devon AONB.

Semi-natural habitats

  • The most extensive habitat designated as SSSI is lowland heath, most of which is in favourable condition and under Higher level stewardship.
  • Changes in agricultural practices have meant a decline in the number of mixed farming practises in the area. This has had an impact on a number of extensively managed habitats and dependent species, particularly grassland sites and hedgerows.
  • The occurrence of flooding has been more frequent in recent years, impacting on the railway line crossing the Exe valley and the branch line to Barnstaple.

Settlement and development

  • Major development is underway at the Exeter and East Devon Growth Point. It includes establishment of the Exeter Science Park, a SkyPark business park, an intermodal rail freight terminaland a new community. Significant infrastructure is also being constructed to service these area. Development pressure is also significant at a local level. The rate of change to urban areas is moderately high, and there is evidence of expansion to the urban fringes areas into the peri-urban zones around Exeter, Exmouth, Budleigh Salterton, Cullompton and Teignmouth. There is also evidence of scattered development in the open countryside and around smaller settlements, including a moderately high rate of barn conversions.
  • Coastal and flood plain grazing marsh is the most extensive BAP habitat in the area, in recent years development and more wide spread flooding has impacted on these areas.

Trees and woodlands

  • Evidence from Countryside Quality Counts for the period from 1999 to 2003 suggests that woodland character is probably not being maintained. While new planting and uptake of management agreements for established stock has increased, there is a significant amount of woodland that is not under agreement. In 1999 uptake of management agreements for established stock, was about 5 per cent of eligible stock identified on the National Inventory of Woodland and Trees, by 2003 this had risen to 14 per cent.

Drivers of Change (reported in 2014)

Climate Change

  • The main issues of predicted climate change, away from the coast, include soil erosion, run off and flooding due to heavy rainfall events, impacting on the region’s mainline railway as well as property.
  • Coastal properties and infrastructure may be particularly vulnerable to flooding and damage with a predicted increased occurrence of severe storms coupled with high tides. These events may also result in landslips along the coast and accentuated cliff erosion.
  • With future predicted rises in sea level, coastal areas will be more vulnerable to flooding, as will settlements around the estuaries as protective spits and bars potentially become inundated. Such inundation will have a significant effect on the biodiversity of the internationally important estuaries, including the iconic avocets on the Exe.
  • As is common across the south coast, the area may be more susceptible to colonisation by migratory species currently not native to England, and particularly flying invertebrates. Northward migration in response to a changing climate may be first recorded throughout this and other coastal areas. Such changes may be particularly significant to the internationally designated Pebblebed Heaths.
  • Conversely, warmer winters could promote increased tree growth, as well as the suitability of new non-native species such as Corsican pine and holm oak, further affecting woodland composition. Other non-native plants such as montbretia and pampas grass are becoming better established and more prominent across the area.

Other key drivers

  • The area east of Exeter is currently undergoing major development and this is planned to continue for the next 15 to 20 years presenting many challenges and opportunities. It is envisaged that 26,600 jobs could potentially be established and 20,000 new homes built. This development will result in a change to the character and tranquillity of this part of the NCA and will present challenges relating to increased traffic, both by road and air, as well as a significant change to the water catchment with flooding, water quality and abstraction issues to consider. Plans to integrate green infrastructure throughout the development will potentially provide numerous new recreational opportunities for residents, provide ecological corridors and could help shape a new landscape with its own distinctive character.
  • The introduction of vertical elements in the landscape such as wind farms may become a significant challenge as the pressure to increase renewable energies continues. The setting of the east side of the NCA may particularly be challenged with developments in the adjoining NCAs and out to sea.
  • The emergence of large scale photovoltaic ‘farms’ and the cumulative impact of smaller units present both challenges and opportunities within this relatively small-scale landscape with a strong sense of place.
  • Existing consents for sand and gravel extraction around the nationally and internationally important East Devon Pebblebed Heaths presents many challenges while the restoration that has occurred will continue into future years provides both biodiversity and recreation opportunities.