National Character Area 34

Bowland Fells - Landscape Change

Monitoring Landscape Change

Drivers for change
The Bowland Fells are an upland landscape, tranquil in character and offering a sense of remoteness as well as important habitat, and are particularly sensitive to changes in rural land management. Increases in recreation and development may affect the historic features, sparse settlement pattern and remote feeling of the uplands. Although overgrazing has significantly impacted the landscape in the past, in-progress restoration and agri-environment schemes may improve the area’s semi-natural habitat and vegetation.

Monitoring landscape change
The most recent monitoring of landscape change within NCAs forms part of the Environmental Improvement Plan Environmental Indicator Framework. This includes indicator G1: Changes in landscape and waterscape character, informed by indicator component G1a: Changes in the landscape characteristics of NCAs in England.

Indicator component G1a measures the extent to which landscape change is achieving the aspirational landscape outcomes described in the NCA Statements of Environmental Opportunity (SEOs). For this purpose, SEOs across all NCAs are distilled into 34 Super Landscape Objectives (SLOs).

NCAs with broadly similar character and pressures for change have been grouped into 18 sub-Agricultural Landscape Types (sub-ALTs) that represent rural, urban and coastal landscapes. Equal numbers of relevant SLOs were identified for monitoring within each sub-ALT and their associated NCAs. These SLOs were assessed based on changes between 2015 – 2023 (or the closest approximations to those dates with the data available). The results of each SLO were combined to form an integrated view of overall landscape change within each NCA during this time period.

For further details on this landscape monitoring, refer to the G1a Landscape Change Atlas and report, which are also available via the Landscape Change Evidence Hub.

Results of G1a: Changes in the landscape characteristics within this NCA
Displayed below is the result of the medium term change assessment which considers the changes in (simplified) overall trend categories for the two short term periods of 2015-2019 and 2019-2023.

This section includes:

  • the overall trend for this NCA for the short term change period 2019-2023
  • the 2019-2023 results of the underlying analysis for each of the individual Super Landscape Objectives considered relevant to the NCA; this includes the ‘provisional status’ (i.e. current understanding of state/condition) and the ‘change trend’ associated with each SLO.

Reporting of the 2015-2019 time period can be seen in the short term change results of G1a: Changes in the landscape characteristics within this NCA below.

Additional information on landscape change

Short term change results of G1a: Changes in the landscape characteristics within this NCA

Listed below are:

    • the overall trend for this NCA for short term change period 2015-2019
    • the results of the underlying analysis for each of the individual Super Landscape Objectives considered relevant to the NCA; this includes the “provisional status” (i.e. current understanding of state/condition) and the “change trend” associated with each SLO for short term change period 2015-2019.

The following SLOs are considered relevant to this NCA. The current provisional status of each objective and the assessment of change (expressed as a trend) is listed below. The overall integrated trend assessment is also listed.

2015 - 2019 change


Landscape change reported in 2014

Recent changes and trends (reported in 2014)

Agriculture

  • Agriculture is dominated by grass and uncropped land, and there was a 10 per cent increase in this land use between 2000 and 2009.
  • Survey data from 2000 to 2009 shows a 26 per cent decrease in the number of dairy farms, while livestock grazing farms have increased by 15 per cent; however both total sheep and cattle numbers have decreased over this time.
  • Overgrazing, drainage and recreational erosion have resulted in loss and degradation of moorland vegetation. However there are extensive areas under agri-environment schemes for management of upland habitats; for example, between 1999 and 2003 Countryside Stewardship uptake for annual area features consistently exceeded the national average. Most agreements in 2003 were for management of heather moorland habitat (8,122 ha), enhancing heather moorland (4,637ha) and management of hay meadows (97 ha).

Boundary features

  • There are many stone walls and field patterns in disrepair. Associated features such as gateposts, sheep folds, stone troughs and parish boundary markers are also at risk.
  • The estimated boundary length for the NCA is about 2,109 km. Total length under Environmental Stewardship agreements as at March 2011 is 408,056 m (19.3 per cent of the total).
  • The most frequent Environmental Stewardship agreements in the area are for stone wall restoration (303,282 m) and hedgerow planting and restoration (60,753 m).

Coast and rivers

  • The Bowland Fells is a major water catchment area. The steep topography and narrow floodplains combine with high rainfall to produce watercourses that respond rapidly to rainfall. The resultant increase in fluvial flood risk occurs in downstream NCAs.
  • Principal surface water resources within the NCA are the catchments of the rivers Lune, Wyre and Ribble as well as Stocks Reservoir on a tributary of the Ribble. The tributaries of the River Lune within the NCA have ‘no water available’. The upper reaches of the River Wyre and its tributaries within the NCA are classified as ‘over abstracted’ or ‘over licensed’.
  • Ecological river water quality is generally good across the NCA’s rivers but falls to moderate in the upper reaches of the Calder, Hindburn and Hodder. The chemical status of groundwater is poor in the north and west of the NCA but good in the south and east.

Historic features

  • Distinctive stone laithe houses and barns as well as the area’s visible archaeological features are at risk and where the farming economy is marginal, lack of maintenance of buildings and management of archaeological sites is a key threat.
  • About 83 per cent of historic farm buildings remained unconverted in 2003, about 80 per cent of which were intact structurally.

Minerals

No information available.

Semi-natural habitats

  • Overgrazing of heather, continuing pressures for drainage of blanket bog and footpath erosion are resulting in damage to heather moorland in some areas. However the majority of moorland SSSIs and commons are reported to be in favourable or recovering condition so the priority is maintenance and restoration.
  • Agricultural improvement through fertilizer and herbicide application has led to former herb-rich meadows and pastures losing their species diversity and conservation value. Lack of traditional management often caused by abandonment of small hill farms due to ongoing economic pressures is also affecting the management of species-rich upland grasslands. This trend is confirmed by a reported increase in rough grazing in the NCA between 1990 and 1998 according to Countryside Quality Counts. In recent years Countryside Stewardship agreements have encouraged management and restoration of in-bye pastures and hay meadows.

Settlement and development

  • Sale and change in management of land held by water authorities and large estates, which forms an integral part of the Bowland Fell moorland fringe landscape, have impacted on character.
  • Villages and farmsteads on the moorland fringe have experienced some suburbanisation, through commuting, home-working, conversion of farm and industrial/retail buildings to residential use, associated car parking, traffic and road improvements, and diversification to tourism related uses. However, pressures for new build are limited due to AONB status.

Trees and woodlands

  • Extensive conifer plantations occur to the south-east of the NCA – Gisburn Forest contains some of the largest areas. The main species is Sitka spruce which has generally been planted in uniform, close-ranked, single species blocks. These are being clear felled and replaced according to forest design plans which will not only add diversity in terms of landscape but also species diversity and wildlife interest. A sizable proportion of the forest has already been restocked with native broadleaved species.
  • The area’s stock of broadleaved woodlands, particularly the unfenced upland woods which provide shelter for stock, is vulnerable to damage by grazing. Countryside Quality Counts data indicates that levels of management of these woodlands are extremely low (4 per cent) and fragmentation is a serious issue.
  • 258 ha of the NCA’s woodland is ancient woodland, of this 8 per cent is plantation on ancient woodland sites. The proportion of these sites covered by a Woodland Grant Scheme agreement increased between 1999 and 2003 from 7 per cent to 18 per cent.

Drivers of Change (reported in 2014)

Climate Change

  • Evidence from UK Climate Impacts Programme (UKCP09) shows that over the coming century the climate in north-west England is expected, on average to become warmer and wetter in winter and hotter and drier in summer. Under the medium emissions scenario by 2080: mean winter temperatures will increase by 2.6°C, mean summer temperatures will increase by 3.7°C, winter precipitation will increase by 16 per cent, summer precipitation will decrease by 22 per cent and there will be an increase frequency of extreme events (floods/droughts).
  • Prolonged periods of drought could lead to reduced ground water and drying out of peat habitats making them more prone to soil erosion and wildfire events.
  • Smaller, fragmented and poor quality habitat patches are vulnerable due to changes in rainfall and temperature.
  • Periods of heavy rain may lead to an increase in flooding downstream and an increased risk of soil erosion or weakened soil structure due to flash flooding. There is also an associated greater likelihood of pollution of watercourses downstream. There is also a potential increased risk of landslides during times of increased rainfall.
  • Threat to trees from changing pests and diseases and extreme weather events.
  • Possible expansion of arable or energy crops into areas currently under permanent grassland but also possibility of more meadows replacing pastures at higher altitudes.
  • There will be pressures for renewable energy development.

Other key drivers

  • Abandonment of hill farming in the face of economic pressure will affect species mix and character of upland habitats.
  • Lack of management of semi-natural clough woodland and lack of restoration of plantation on ancient woodland sites may reduce wildlife value.
  • Agricultural specialisation, intensification, and farm amalgamation may result in a loss of semi-natural habitat and cultural features.
  • Heavy fertiliser use and diffuse pollution can lead to loss of biodiversity both on and off agricultural land as well as affecting water quality.
  • The negotiation of appropriate moorland management regimes, to achieve good condition of the vegetation and water quality, including the restoration of bare peat and degraded blanket bog remains a key issue.
  • There is an opportunity to increase tree and woodland cover to provide multiple benefits including reconnecting fragmented habitats increasing resilience and improving water quality.
  • Pressure on key destinations can result in erosion and potential damage to archaeological sites, loss of habitat, tranquillity and diminished visitor experience.
  • Development, traffic and lighting outside the NCA will increasingly intrude on the quality of the landscape.
  • Pressure for new development and building conversion in open exposed landscapes can be visually intrusive.
  • There will be increased pressure for commercial scale renewable energy infrastructure, such as windfarms.
  • There are opportunities for the sensitive management of access provision to minimise visitor pressures, and enhance visitor experiences and benefits. Positive visitor experiences are likely to benefit the local economy through increased number of visits, longer stays and recommendations to others, with the promotion of the Bowland brand and other sustainable initiatives being an increasingly important part of a growing green economy.