National Character Area 88

Bedfordshire and Cambridgeshire Claylands - Landscape Change

Monitoring Landscape Change

Drivers for change
The Bedfordshire and Cambridgeshire Claylands are a broad, gently undulating, lowland plateau dissected by shallow river valleys, where drier summers could increase wildfires in grassland and wood habitats, and heavier winter rainfall could impact soil and water quality, with flooding following heavier rainfall. Proximity to London and population growth creates pressure to develop more housing as well as improve existing stock, both of which threaten the tranquillity and historic character of the area.

Monitoring landscape change
The most recent monitoring of landscape change within NCAs forms part of the Environmental Improvement Plan Environmental Indicator Framework. This includes indicator G1: Changes in landscape and waterscape character, informed by indicator component G1a: Changes in the landscape characteristics of NCAs in England.

Indicator component G1a measures the extent to which landscape change is achieving the aspirational landscape outcomes described in the NCA Statements of Environmental Opportunity (SEOs). For this purpose, SEOs across all NCAs are distilled into 34 Super Landscape Objectives (SLOs).

NCAs with broadly similar character and pressures for change have been grouped into 18 sub-Agricultural Landscape Types (sub-ALTs) that represent rural, urban and coastal landscapes. Equal numbers of relevant SLOs were identified for monitoring within each sub-ALT and their associated NCAs. These SLOs were assessed based on changes between 2015 – 2023 (or the closest approximations to those dates with the data available). The results of each SLO were combined to form an integrated view of overall landscape change within each NCA during this time period.

For further details on this landscape monitoring, refer to the G1a Landscape Change Atlas and report, which are also available via the Landscape Change Evidence Hub.

Results of G1a: Changes in the landscape characteristics within this NCA
Displayed below is the result of the medium term change assessment which considers the changes in (simplified) overall trend categories for the two short term periods of 2015-2019 and 2019-2023.

This section includes:

  • the overall trend for this NCA for the short term change period 2019-2023
  • the 2019-2023 results of the underlying analysis for each of the individual Super Landscape Objectives considered relevant to the NCA; this includes the ‘provisional status’ (i.e. current understanding of state/condition) and the ‘change trend’ associated with each SLO.

Reporting of the 2015-2019 time period can be seen in the short term change results of G1a: Changes in the landscape characteristics within this NCA below.

Additional information on landscape change

Short term change results of G1a: Changes in the landscape characteristics within this NCA

Listed below are:

    • the overall trend for this NCA for short term change period 2015-2019
    • the results of the underlying analysis for each of the individual Super Landscape Objectives considered relevant to the NCA; this includes the “provisional status” (i.e. current understanding of state/condition) and the “change trend” associated with each SLO for short term change period 2015-2019.

The following SLOs are considered relevant to this NCA. The current provisional status of each objective and the assessment of change (expressed as a trend) is listed below. The overall integrated trend assessment is also listed.

2015 - 2019 change


Landscape change reported in 2014

Recent changes and trends (reported in 2014)

Agriculture

  • Farm amalgamation associated with an increase in agricultural productivity has created an intensively farmed landscape consisting of medium and large arable fields. This has resulted in the loss of hedgerows, fragmentation and loss of semi-natural habitats, particularly grasslands, and damage to underground archaeology and historic features.
  • A subtle change in land use has occurred around small villages and settlements where small grass paddocks for keeping of horses and ponies have been accommodated, impacting on local landscape character.
  • The NCA remains predominantly agricultural in nature; however, between 2000 and 2009 the area of land under livestock, arable, horticulture and mixed cropping fell as land was converted to other uses or developed. The area under grass remained fairly static, although total farm size and the area of land held by farms also fell.
  • In 2003, Countryside Stewardship agreements were based on arable options and followed the national average. These included overwintered stubble followed by a spring/summer fallow (102 ha), overwintered stubble followed by a low input spring cereal crop (29 ha), overwintered stubble followed by a spring crop (26 ha), wild bird seed mixture (58 ha), creation of permanent grass margins > 6 m (852 km), creation of 2 m wide arable margins (218 km), creation of 2 m wide grass margins or beetle banks (242 km), and buffer strips (4 km). The area of lowland pastures on neutral/acid soils and lowland hay meadows under agreement was 1,454 ha and 800 ha respectively. Environmental Stewardship (Entry Level and Higher Level) options taken (2005 to 2011) include 271 ha of overwintered stubble, 44 ha of wild bird seed mixture and 376 ha of buffer strips to cultivated land, grassland and watercourses.

Boundary features

  • The predominance of commercial arable production, farm amalgamation and a need to accommodate modern agricultural equipment has led to the removal of some hedgerows and an increase in field size. Neglect and inappropriate management of hedgerows are key issues with many becoming gappy, overly-trimmed and species-poor. Where hedgerows are absent, particularly in parts of the NCA in Cambridgeshire, the fields may be bounded by open ditches, which may also be similarly neglected or inappropriately managed.
  • In 2003 only a small proportion (3 per cent or 410 km) of the estimated boundary length for this NCA (13,663 km) was under Countryside Stewardship agreements. This included 76 km of fencing, 96 km of hedgerow management, 146 km of hedgerow planting and restoration, and 37 km of restored-boundary protection. Similarly there were limited agreements for ditches (4 km). Data suggests that uptake of boundary options significantly increased with Environmental Stewardship; Entry Level and Higher Level Stewardship options taken since 2005 include 945 km of hedgerow management, 24 km of hedgerow restoration, 9.4 km of hedgerow planting and 156 km of ditch management and restoration.
  • Dutch elm disease had a dramatic effect on hedgerow trees in the NCA resulting in the loss of many. Remaining hedgerow trees and those located by ditches are mainly oak and ash. A small-scale project has begun to reintroduce English elm to the Marston Vale using potentially disease-resistant plants.

Coast and rivers

  • The whole of the NCA area has been identified as a nitrate vulnerable zone (NVZ) with measures in place to improve water quality. The potential ecological status of the majority of the waterbodies in the NCA has been recorded as moderate. The groundwater status in the majority of the NCA has been recorded as poor. The Cam and Ely Woburn Sands and Secondary Upper Bedford Ouse Oolite aquifers have good status.
  • Water resources have come increasingly pressured due to demands for water for agriculture, spray irrigation, industrial use, power generation and public water supply. Water availability within the NCA is restricted with many waterbodies currently listed as having no water available.
  • Flood risk occurs along the course of the River Great Ouse and within the catchment. Many rivers have been heavily modified, embanked or re-sectioned with weirs and flood defence structures in place to manage water flows. The catchment is known for its quick response during periods of heavy rainfall and for water quality and flow issues further downstream that affect important sites of nature conservation interest for example Nene and Ouse Washes.
  • Grafham Water near Huntingdon was constructed in the 1960s to meet the demand for water from the new town of Milton Keynes and the rapid expansion of Bedfordshire’s and Northamptonshire’s existing towns. It is one of the largest man-made reservoirs in England and an important location for water-based recreation and nature conservation.
  • Some invasive species, such as signal crayfish and Himalayan balsam, thrive in the River Great Ouse catchment at the expense of native species. Dikerogammarus villosus, an invasive freshwater shrimp, has been found at Grafham Water. Measures are in place to help control its spread.

Historic features

  • A small proportion of the NCA is historic parkland, much of which is included on the Register of Historic Parks and Gardens (39 sites). The resource is considerably smaller in extent than it was in 1918. By 1995 it is estimated that 53 per cent of parkland had been lost. About 35 per cent of the remaining parkland is covered by a Historic Parkland Grant, and about 18 per cent of this is included within an agri-environment scheme.
  • Approximately 67 per cent of historic farm buildings remain unconverted.
  • One of the Cardington Hangars, a local landmark and historic feature which was registered by English Heritage as being at risk, is currently undergoing restoration work.

Minerals

  • The extensive extraction of clay in the Marston Vale, Bedfordshire and in the brickfields of Peterborough has created a distinct landscape of deep excavations and man-made waterbodies. Many have been restored for recreation, biodiversity as well as being used for landfill, particularly within the Marston Vale, creating a unique domed landscape within the gently undulating arable plateau.
  • Sand and gravel extraction within the river valleys, especially along the River Great Ouse, has left a series of restored and flooded waterbodies important for biodiversity, recreation and in some cases water management for the catchment.
  • While economic factors have slowed the rate of mineral extraction some continues and the area has rich deposits of clay, sand and gravel which could be exploited in future.

Semi-natural habitats

  • The main semi-natural habitats within the NCA include flood plain grazing marsh, lowland mixed deciduous woodland, wood pasture and parkland, fen, lowland meadow and reedbed. All have become reduced in size and more fragmented.
  • Around Somersham and Bluntisham in Cambridgeshire some good examples of traditional orchard remain. The area of remaining traditional orchard in the county is thought to be 20 per cent of what the total area was in 1950 with losses still occurring due to development, neglect and land use change such as conversion to arable or paddocks.
  • Countryside Stewardship uptake for the area followed the national average. Agreements included pastures on neutral/acid soils (1,454 ha), lowland hay meadows (800 ha) and grassland/semi-natural vegetation regeneration (567 ha). Environmental Stewardship (Entry Level and Higher Level) options taken between 2005 and 2011 included 328 ha of wood pasture and parkland management and restoration, 11 ha of orchard management and 340 ha of species-rich grassland management and restoration.

Settlement and development

  • Development pressure in the NCA is high. There has been significant development, both residential and commercial, around many of the major towns and within villages. Development around Milton Keynes, Bedford, Biggleswade, St Neots, Huntingdon, Peterborough and Cambridge, in particular, has been extensive. There are growth plans for all of the main towns and cities and Milton Keynes continues to expand.
  • A large proportion of development has taken place within growth areas around Milton Keynes, Cambridge and Peterborough, and along major transport corridors such as the A1, M1 and M11. This includes transport infrastructure improvements such as widening of sections of the A1 and M1, a new section of the A421 between Junction 13 of the M1 and the A1, and duelling of the A428 between Caxton Gibbett and Cambridge impacting on local landscape character.
  • Airfields built in the Second World War have been given a new lease of life as business hubs and local airports or are awaiting a second phase of development often including residential development.
  • As renewable energy technology, particularly wind energy, has developed the area has been subject to proposals for generating renewable energy with pressure to accommodate wind turbines. A number have been given permission most notably near Gravely, Biggleswade, St Neots and Olney.

Trees and woodlands

  • Between 1999 and 2003 the area of woodland covered by a Woodland Grant Scheme in the NCA rose from 15 per cent to 23 per cent. Four hundred and fifty-five hectares was approved for new planting through the Woodland Grant Scheme and the proportion of ancient woodland sites covered by a Woodland Grant Scheme agreement rose from 16 per cent to 38 per cent. Agreements included the expansion of wet woodland and lowland broadleaved woodland. Along river valleys some willow pollarding and planting of native black poplar has taken place grant-aided by various means including agri-environment schemes and landfill tax, as well as by local authorities, environmental charities and statutory agencies.
  • New woodland planting can be found throughout the NCA in small scattered blocks and corners of arable fields. Woodland cover has increased through the ongoing creation of the Forest of Marston Vale Community Forest in Bedfordshire. This is one of 12 Community Forests set up in England in 1990/91. In 1995 woodland cover in the Marston Vale was 3 per cent which had risen to 9 per cent in 2009/10 as a result of new planting. The target set by Government is for 30 per cent tree/woodland cover within the Community Forest area by 2031. In Cambridgeshire the Wildlife Trust is undertaking work with landowners to link some of the remaining ancient woodlands around Gamlingay, Gransden and Waresley.

Drivers of Change (reported in 2014)

Climate Change

  • Current agricultural practices may need to adapt to likely changes in weather patterns and water availability. Greater demands on agriculture to produce higher yields could put pressure on the remaining areas of semi-natural grassland, woodland, wetland and other semi-natural habitats.
  • Changing temperatures and weather conditions such as warmer, drier summers could lead to a longer growing season and the ability to grow different types of crops. However, a reduction in winter cropping and winter stubbles could reduce available food sources for farmland birds. There may be an increased demand for energy crops that changes cropping patterns and impacts on landscape character. Careful management may be required to ensure this does not lead to a deterioration in soil and water quality, through the run-off of soil nutrients, sediment and diffuse pollution from herbicides and pesticides.
  • An increase in extreme weather events – hotter, drier summers and heavier winter rainfall -could result in an increase in the incidence of grassland and woodland fires during dry summers with impacts on soil and water quality and flooding following heavier rainfall. Flood plain grazing marsh may benefit from wetter winters, but suffer from summer droughts. Periods of drought may alter the species composition of semi-natural habitats, particularly woodland and grassland, so that species more tolerant of drought conditions dominate those that are not. Increases in sediment loads and run-off may affect water quality and have adverse effects on habitats, species and designated sites along river valleys, especially those further downstream.
  • Wind blow and drought may lead to the loss of ancient and veteran trees in hedgerows and parkland landscapes impacting on landscape character. There may even be a decline in the amount of woodland cover and changes in species abundance including those that specialise in decaying and dead wood.
  • Climate change may make some tree species more vulnerable to pests and disease, or vulnerable to competition from invasive species. Warmer winters may allow new pests and diseases to become a potential threat. Changes in climate may also make it easier for non-native and other invasive species to move within the landscape to the detriment of native ones.
  • With warmer weather it is likely that there will be an increase in demand for outdoor recreation during the summer adding further pressure on popular recreation sites. Additional path and visitor facility maintenance may be required. Ground conditions and storm damage in the winter may hinder access or detract from the user experience. Where habitats are fragmented they are likely to be more vulnerable to degradation and damage, and sensitive species more likely to be disturbed.

Other key drivers

  • Development pressure in this NCA is high and continues to grow due to expanding populations and proximity to London. Further growth and infrastructure improvements are planned, such as upgrading the A14 and a new waterway link between Milton Keynes and Bedford. The need to accommodate this further growth and expansion will present a challenge in ensuring that the character and tranquillity of the area are not adversely affected. Opportunities exist to improve multi-functional green infrastructure links and the design of the urban fringes in ways that respect landscape character and improve access to the countryside for local communities.
  • There are significant pressures on the water resources within the NCA which are likely to intensify with the impact of growth and development, recreational and agricultural demands, and climate change. Water management will be an increasingly major challenge. The NCA is in one of the driest parts of the UK with low rainfall. It contains a number of important wildlife sites reliant on a good supply of water of high quality and it suffers from high flood risk in some areas which impacts on water quality. Opportunities exist to address some of these challenges and bring wider benefits by reconnecting the river with its flood plain and increasing its water storage capacity.
  • Within the Marston Vale the work of the Community Forest to regenerate the landscape affected by the brick-making industry will continue to 2031. Trees and woodlands are being used to regenerate the landscape and provide social, economic and environmental benefits. Partnership projects and initiatives such as Bedford River Valley Park, on the eastern side of Bedford, offer multiple benefits for recreation, biodiversity, education, protection of heritage assets, climate regulation and an opportunity to restore a functioning flood plain. The impact of ash die-back in the NCA caused by the fungus Chalara fraxinea is currently unknown; however, it could have a potentially significant impact as ash is a common and characteristic tree species of the area.